The Long Island Lolita
How did a quiet Long Island family become a national obsession?
4.4 (35)
95 mins
A suburban shooting unraveled a hidden affair, calculated deception, and one of America's biggest media frenzies. As the truth emerged, the case became a lasting debate over manipulation, justice, and accountability.
Ep 1:
Gunshot on Porch
A teenager's gunshot exposed a web of secret affairs, manipulation, and betrayal. Obsession, hidden relationships, and tabloid sensationalism blurred the line between victim and villain.
Ep 2:
Paper Trail Affair
Hidden evidence exposed a secret affair, a manipulated teenager, and months of calculated deception, revealing that the shooting was not an isolated act but a web of lies that divided the entire nation.
Ep 3:
Stalker Claim Falls
Detectives dismantled Joey Buttafuoco's carefully crafted "stalker" narrative through pager records, forensic ballistics, and handwriting analysis, exposing a hidden affair built on deception.
Ep 4:
Justice Sparks Outrage
Controversial plea deals, unequal sentences, and relentless media attention sparked a nationwide debate over justice. Discover the final vedict and what happened after that.
Discussions (5)
Wanda
Level 6 · 2 mo agoJoey serving 4 months while Amy got 5-15 years is not justice, that's a joke
Hannah
Level 3 · 2 mo agoSaying Amy approached two men before Guagenti doesn't automatically prove cold premeditation. A groomed teenager in emotional crisis can still plan something while being completely psychologically broken. Both things are true at once.
Ryland
Level 3 · 2 mo agoAmy walking up with a loaded gun and prior attempts to hire someone proves premeditation, yet the podcast keeps softening it with exploitation framing. Both things can be true without one canceling the other out.
