History of Thanksgiving

Is Thanksgiving a true celebration of gratitude or a myth?

4.2 (36)

41 mins

Explore the hidden roots of Thanksgiving, from peaceful treaties and brutal battles to presidential proclamations and modern traditions. Discover how myths, political struggles, Indigenous influences, and even football helped shape the holiday’s evolving meaning.

Ep 1:

Myths, Massacres, and Minister's Footnotes

Peel back the pilgrim postcard: discover how a 19th-century minister's footnote invented 'the first Thanksgiving,' and why linking the holiday to a colonial massacre doesn't hold up to scrutiny.

Ep 2:

Turkey Day Politics and Gridiron Glory

From Washington's controversial proclamation to FDR's 'Franksgiving' fiasco, and from Rutgers' first kickoff to the Lions' Thanksgiving dynasty, discover how politics and pigskin shaped America's favorite holiday.

Ep 3:

From Sacred Squash to Sunday Sides

Your favorite Thanksgiving side dishes have secret histories. Trace succotash and pumpkin pie from ancient Indigenous innovations to the sweetened, Europeanized dishes on today's tables.

Ep 4:

Presidents, Prayers, and Constitutional Clashes

Dive deeper into the constitutional firestorms Thanksgiving proclamations ignited, then trace how the holiday's Puritan piety evolved into today's inclusive, resilient American tradition.

Ep 5:

The Real Meaning Behind the Feast

As our journey ends, we ask what four centuries of myth, politics, and culinary evolution really reveal about why Thanksgiving still matters to imperfect, grateful Americans.

Download the App

And Listen to Full Podcast