The Caffey Family Murders
What drove a teenager to help plan the murder of her own family?
4.7 (35)
29 mins
Discover how 16-year-old Erin Caffey became involved in a plot that led to the murders of her mother and two brothers in their Texas home. Explore the relationships, resentment, and decisions that turned a family conflict into a deadly plan.
Ep 1:
The Choir Girl's Secret
Behind the Caffey family's quiet Texas faith and homeschooled stability, a forbidden romance with a troubled boy named Charlie sets a devastating betrayal into motion.
Ep 2:
The Night the House Burned
A midnight plan hatched in a cemetery leads to gunfire, swords, and fire inside the Caffey home—leaving one father to crawl for his life and a daughter hiding under a wig.
Ep 3:
The Best Liar He Ever Met
As accomplices point fingers at Erin and her own words unravel her story, investigators and family grapple with whether she was mastermind or manipulated teenager.
Ep 4:
A Father's Forgiveness
Terry Caffey confronts rage, a loaded gun, and grief in a burned-out home before choosing an unimaginable path toward forgiving the daughter who helped destroy his family.
Discussions (5)
Garrett
Level 7 · 5 days agoTerry crawling 300 yards shot 11 times is insane
Reece
Level 10 · 5 days agoShot 11 times, crawled 300 yards, survived. Charlie gave his grandma's ring and lost everything. Terry won.
Duane
Level 6 · 5 days agoTerry crawling 300 yards to his neighbor's house is confirmed. Court records and news coverage back this up completely. He was shot 11 times and made it through a creek. That part is not exaggerated at all.
