Sonia Exelby's Murder
How did an online connection turn deadly?
4.4 (20)
29 mins
Discover the murder of 32-year-old British music tutor Sonia Exelby, who traveled from Portsmouth to Florida in October 2025 after communicating online with Hall. Explore how she failed to board her return flight, was reported missing, and was later found buried in a shallow grave in Marion County, with her death ruled a homicide.
Ep 1:
A Pact Made in the Dark
A music teacher's secret descent into a fetish forum's darkest corners leads to a one-way flight to Florida — and a pact that would cost her everything.
Ep 2:
The Cabin at the Edge of Nowhere
Isolated in a remote Florida cabin, Sonia's plan unravels in terror as a desperate late-night message reveals she never truly wanted to die.
Ep 3:
Harold, Lies, and a Burner Confession
Caught in a web of declined cards and digital trails, Dwayne Hall spins an outlandish cover story — until the evidence forces a chilling confession.
Ep 4:
The Knife He Couldn't Let Go
A hidden grave, a stolen knife, and a jailhouse boast expose the cold calculation behind Sonia's murder — and the fight for justice that follows.
Discussions (5)
Ryder
Level 6 · 3 days agoMotherless still runs after 2026 raids
Stone
Level 3 · 3 days agocalling it assisted suicide is a stretch, he just wanted money
Sylvester
Level 4 · 3 days agoHe sent the murder weapon to Ohio for safekeeping and called it precious. Dwayne was cooked the moment he got sentimental
