Cindy Collier & Shirley Wolf
What drove the actions in the Cindy Collier and Shirley Wolf case?
4.7 (40)
62 mins
Discover the events involving Cindy Collier and Shirley Wolf and the circumstances that led to the case. Uncover how the incident was investigated and what it revealed about youth behavior, influence, and consequences.
Ep 1:
Two Strangers, One Highway Ambush
A son drives past his mother's killers on Highway 51, unaware that two teenage strangers who bonded a day earlier just committed unspeakable murder in Auburn, 1983.
Ep 2:
Rage Meets Rage: A Deadly Bond
Fourteen-year-old Shirley Wolf and fifteen-year-old Cindy Collier, both scarred by years of abuse, instantly bond in a group home—forging a friendship built on shared trauma and murderous intent.
Ep 3:
The Kindness That Killed Anna Brackett
After surviving one close call, the girls find eighty-five-year-old Anna Brackett alone, whose trusting kindness becomes the very thing that seals her horrifying, violent fate.
Ep 4:
It Was Lots of Fun
Sleeping soundly after the murder, Cindy and Shirley show chilling euphoria instead of remorse, as Shirley's diary entry reveals a disturbing craving for more violence.
Ep 5:
Judgment, Insanity, and a Broken Bond
As courts weigh insanity pleas and juvenile justice limits, the girls face judgment for their crime—only to watch their once-inseparable bond shatter into bitter hatred behind bars.
Ep 6:
After the Blood: Two Divergent Lives
Decades after the murder, Cindy and Shirley walk vastly different paths—one rebuilding quietly, the other seeking redemption—leaving haunting questions about monsters, victims, and accountability.
Discussions (5)
Stella
Level 6 · 5 mo agoKilling an innocent woman for a car you do not even know how to start is peak dark irony. Imagine bonding over trauma and deciding your first DIY project together is a deeply incompetent murder.
Graham
Level 5 · 5 mo agoNope, some are born evil.
Keith
Level 4 · 5 mo agoCindy got a law degree?
