Chacey Poynter's Crime
How did a rescue call become murder?
4.1 (15)
34 mins
Discover how Chacey Poynter's husband, Texas firefighter Robert Poynter, was shot in the head after she called him to a remote dirt road in September 2016. Uncover how Chacey initially told police that a mysterious man had emerged from the darkness and killed Robert while he was helping her with her Jeep.
Ep 1:
A Captain Dead on a Dirt Road
A frantic 911 call leads deputies to a muddy Texas road where a beloved fire captain lies shot dead—and his unharmed wife's story doesn't add up.
Ep 2:
The Wife, the Affairs, and the Motive
Behind the devoted marriage lurked bitter fights, four secret lovers, and a fabricated abuse story—all pointing toward a chilling financial motive.
Ep 3:
Luring Robert to the Kill Spot
Text by text, the night unravels: a staged breakdown, a loaded shotgun, and a husband walked hand-in-hand into an ambush he never saw coming.
Ep 4:
Justice for the Fire Captain
Forensic evidence and a chilling interrogation seal two convictions, while a grieving fire department and a motherless little girl are left to pick up the pieces.
Discussions (5)
Torey
Level 2 · 2 weeks agoChasey never coming out for parole after 30 years is wishful thinking. Texas parole board releases people constantly regardless of crime severity. That 30 year mark is going to be a real fight for Roberts family.
Scott
Level 9 · 2 weeks agoThe cologne detail destroyed me. He showed up wearing it hoping to reconnect and she used that hope against him. That's the most heartbreaking part of the whole thing.
Christopher
Level 10 · 2 weeks agoChasey spent the afternoon in bed with the guy she hired to kill her husband then sent Robert lovey texts for 2 hours. She walked him to his death giggling about tacos.
